Richard Hunn Association for Ch'an Study (UK)
  • Home
  • About
    • Aims & Objectives
    • Ch'an Blog (釋大道)
    • Remembering Norwich Ch’an Association
    • Biography: Master Xu Yun (1840-1959)
  • Translations
  • Articles
  • Membership of RHACS
  • Ch'an Retreats
  • International Wisdom Society
  • Qianfeng Daoism
  • Contact

Being ‘Unmoved’ By Praise and Blame

1/29/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
Life and Death Are of Equal Worth
Many people are surprised to learn that Master Xu Yun (1840-1959) was subject to a more or less continuous stream of allegations claiming that he routinely ‘broke’ the Vinaya Discipline and the Bodhisattva Vows. These assertions were usually made by common people with an axe to grind for some reason or other. The fact that no one took these allegations seriously is simply because no one who mattered believed any of it to be true. Master Xu Yun was accused of seducing young girls and women, as well as pursuing homosexual relationships with young monks. When these reports were found to be groundless – Master Xu Yun was accused of amassing money and using it to lead a life of luxury and leisure! Again, no evidence was ever found and so these allegations were ignored like all the others. When he was married (in his late teens) Master Xu Yun never touched his two wives. Years later, this was confirmed by these (now elderly) ladies who had become ordained Buddhist nuns after their husband left to become a monk around 1858. These ladies were virginal when they entered the Buddhist nunnery. 
Picture
A Genuine Master 'Sees Beyond' Surface Impressions
My personal experience of Chinese monastic communities, as well as from the memories of other Western people who also lived as a Buddhist monk in China, confirm that homosexuality (as well as any type of sexual expression) was not present. This is because the facility of human desire is ‘turned inward’ and transmutated into pure spiritual light and energy that emanates from the centre of the forehead and from there permeates the entire body and environment. This process detaches sexual energy from the sexual organs and diverts the imagination of the mind away from sexual fulfilment through the sexual organ, focusing on ‘returning’ all this sensation back toward the empty mind ground. There is no outward sexual reaction or perversion within the average Chinese Ch’an monastery because the subject-object dichotomy that drives the sexual drive within delusive society no longer exists.  ​
Picture
Even Dangerous Wild Animals Can 'Sense' Motive
There is a point in this process where the sexual drive is transformed forever regardless of circumstance. Although a conducive environment is beneficially to start with, eventually, once the six senses are permanently ‘purified’ and ‘cleansed’, then a lay-men such as Vimalakirti and Hui Neng (prior to the latter’s eventual ordination) where able to live within ordinary society and yet never break their Vinaya Discipline. Vimalakirti had a number of wives and numerous children – and yet the Buddha stated that he ‘never’ broke the vow of celibacy. Vimalakirti also criticised the Buddha’s ordained disciple Upali (a Master of the Vinaya Disciple) for being attached (in the wrong) way to the ‘letter of the law’. Vimalakirti stated that being ‘attached’ to celibacy in such a one-sided manner was as bad as being mindlessly attached to sexual pleasure! The answer is that ‘pleasure’, ‘pain’ and ‘neutrality’ are all perceived to be equally ‘empty’ of any and all permanent reality. All emerge from the empty mind ground as karmic attributes that simply take the form that is implicitly conditioned within each strand of expression. This Mahayana penetrating of all phenomena is very different to Upali’s Hinayana notion of just avoiding ‘pleasure’, etc.  
Picture
The Empty Mind-Ground is Always 'Pristine'
It is the same for ‘praise’ and ‘blame’, as both are equally ‘empty’ of any intrinsic or separate value. A practitioner who has penetrated the empty mind ground exists in a permanent state of divine indifference and are unmoved by either praise or blame. Reacting to the ignorance of others with the same ignorance does not happen because it cannot happen. Once the empty mind ground has been permanently penetrated, understood and integrated with, then there is never any slipping back to a more deficient position of understanding. People who operate through the ego are continuously attempting to make some kind of social gain through manipulating those around them.  A Ch’an Master sees this straightaway and reveals the underlying reality of those who approach with ulterior motives. All is wisdom, loving kindness and compassion.  
Picture
Human Discrimination Categories Phenomena into 'Good', 'Bad' and 'Indifferent' Categorisations
0 Comments

Turning Around in the Deepest Recesses of the Mind

10/6/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Adrian (Left), Gee (Centre), Sue-Ling (Right) - Sutton United Football Ground - 2002
I respect the Theravada School and have trained with its monks and nuns many times. I admire its Dhamma and work to protect and preserve it in Sri Lanka, Thailand and Myanmar, etc. However, there are certain differences of view which I wish to explore (although in my own training, I see no difference). The Theravada view (for many but not all) is that the senses are purified when the body (and mind) is removed from direct contact with a polluting environment (such as when entering a forest temple or monastery, etc). Only a monastic can purify their minds fully, with a lay man purifying his mind to a lesser degree than the average monastic, but certainly more so than a lay woman. The Ch’an School rejects this view. As the empty mind ground underlies ALL phenomenal existence, the idea that only monks (or nuns) can fully realise it does not hold, and is contradicted by the numerous examples of enlightened lay men and women in the Pali Suttas, and the Ch’an tradition (including children) within China (Vimlakirti is perhaps the greatest Indian example), but what does this difference mean in reality? The Theravada method suggests that enlightenment - I.e. the uprooting of greed, hatred and delusion – is dependent upon circumstance and is only possible if an individual is ‘removed’ from direct contact with the ordinary world. Then, the corrupting influence of the three taints diminishes and eventually falls away (as all stimulus ceases). However, should such an individual be plummeted back into the ordinary world, then this deluded mechanism would re-active and the mind be yet again consumed by greed, hatred and delusion.  The Ch’an method ensures that whilst living in isolation, or at least relative peace for a while, the mind calms to a considerable degree so that the hua tou and gong-an methods can ‘return’ ALL sensory stimulus back to the empty mind ground from which it originated. Once the hearing has been returned, all the other five senses are also returned, and the empty mind ground fully penetrated and realised. This experience automatically ‘purifies’ the six senses in a permanent manner that cannot ever be re-corrupted. This is why the Ch’an School advocates the ‘Ch’an Week’, or periods of intense meditative activity interspersed with weeks (or months) of quite ordinary and mundane activity. This explains why many Ch’an monastics either return to lay life to spread compassion and wisdom throughout society, or hold office or other positions within the lay world as monastics with no problem whatsoever. It makes no difference where their expedient body resides, as the six senses have been fully imbued (and transformed) through the presence of a pervasive and all-embracing ‘emptiness’ which is as purifying as it is compassionate and full of loving kindness. This reality further explains why many Ch’an practitioners refuse to ordain in China, as there is no need to do so.  
0 Comments

    Author

    My name is Adrian Chan-Wyles (Upasaka Heng Yu) - also known as ‘Shi Da Dao’. At the moment I am neither attached to the void, nor hindered by phenomena. Eventually I shall attempt to pass away sat upright with a clear mind.  

    Picture

    Archives

    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019

    Categories

    All
    100 Foot Pole
    10 Ox-Herding
    1962
    1970s
    2002
    2005
    5 Stages
    61s Anniversary
    6 Senses
    6th Patriarch
    Accuracy
    Airport
    Alignment
    All Embracing
    All-embracing
    Ancient India
    Anxiety
    Archery
    Artist
    Artwork
    Awareness
    Behaviour
    Bhavana
    Black Robe
    Bodhi
    Bodhimandala
    Bodhisattva
    Bodhisattva Vow
    Bombing
    Buddha
    Buddhapadipa
    Buddhism
    Cancer
    Canopy
    Cao Dong
    Caodong School
    Caoshan
    Caring
    Carl Jung
    Chan
    Ch'an
    Ch'an
    Ch'an Buddhism
    Ch'an Dialogue
    Ch'an Lineage
    Ch'an Monk
    Ch'an School
    Ch'an Week
    Charles Luk
    Charles Luk (1898-1978)
    China
    Chinese
    Choice
    Choices
    Circumstance
    Combat
    Compassion
    Consciousness
    Context
    COVID19
    Cutting Through
    Dao
    Daoism
    Daughter
    Death
    Delusion
    Dharma
    Dharma-Successor
    Dharma Words
    Dialogue
    Discipline
    Distraction
    Distress
    Divine
    Divine Silence
    Dogen
    Dojo
    Dongshan
    Drawing
    Dualism
    Dust
    Effort
    Emotion
    Empathy
    Emptiness
    Empty
    Empty Circle
    Empty Mind Ground
    Enlightenment
    Essence
    Eternal
    Evil Deeds
    Existence
    Expanded
    Expedient
    Externality
    False Ch'an
    FanShe
    Fear
    Five Ranks
    Flight
    Focus
    Form
    Four Noble Truths
    Free
    Freedom
    Fullcircle
    Full Enlightenment
    Future
    GF Sutton
    Gift
    Gong-an
    Great Pearl
    Guangdong
    Guangong
    Guest
    Guidance
    Han Shan (憨山)
    Heart
    Help
    Heng
    Here
    Here And Now
    HG Wells
    Hinayana
    Homelessness
    Honey
    Hope
    Host
    Host In Host
    Hua Tou
    Hui Neng
    Hui Neng (坐化)
    Humanity
    Illiteracy
    Imperial Japan
    India
    Indifference
    Inner
    Inner Gazing
    Inner Vision
    Insight
    Instruction
    Integration
    Interior
    Isolation
    Japan
    John Blofeld
    Kamma
    Karma
    Karuna
    Klesa
    Kong Xin Di
    Kyoto
    Laity
    Lamp
    Language
    Lankavatara Sutra
    Lay Enlightenment
    Lay Practice
    Lay-practice
    Life
    Lineage
    Logic
    Love
    Loving Kindness
    Loving-kindness
    Lu Kuan Yu
    Mahayana
    Mahayana Sutras
    Master
    Master Hai Hui
    Master Han Shan Deqing
    Master Hongyi
    Master Huaixi
    Master Wu Yunqing
    Master Xu Yun
    Master Xu Yun (1840-1959)
    Materialism
    Matter
    Meditation
    Metta
    Miao Lian
    Mind
    Mind Ground
    Mind-ground
    Mind Precept
    Minister
    Mirror
    Mirror Samadhi
    Modern World
    Monasticism
    Monasticsm
    Monk
    Morality
    Mortal Coil
    Movement
    Neidan
    Non-attachment
    'not Born'
    Obscuration
    Oil
    Old Master
    Outer
    Oxford University
    Painting
    Pali Suttas
    Panna
    Paravritti
    Past
    Patanjali
    Patient Endurance
    Peace
    Penetration
    Peng Yun
    Perfection
    Portrait
    Post-enlightenment
    Poverty
    Power
    Prajna
    Prajna Sword
    Prediction
    Present
    Present Moment
    Prince
    Psychic Fabric
    Public
    Purifying Senses
    Purity
    Qiao Seng
    Reading
    Realisation
    Reality
    Reason
    Rebirth
    Red Army
    Reflection
    Reincarnation
    Relative Enlightenment
    Retreat
    RHACS
    Richard Hunn
    Richard Hunn (1949-2006)
    Right-side
    Sad Monk
    Sanskrit
    Sanskrit Sutras
    Schoolboy
    Science
    Scott Martinez.
    Seated Transformation
    Seeking
    Self-enlightenment
    Self-Isolation
    Self-study
    Shaolin
    Shi
    Shi Da Dao
    Shrine
    Soto
    South Korea
    Spirit
    Stability
    Stationary
    Still Mind
    Stillness
    Sue Ling Chan-Wyles
    Sunyata
    Supportive
    Surangama Sutra
    Surface Mind
    Sutras
    Sutton United
    Taeko Watani
    Tantrayana
    Teenager
    The Buddha Box
    Theravada School
    Transformation
    Transmission
    Travelling
    'turning About'
    UK
    Uncreate
    Upasaka
    Upasaka Heng Yu
    Upasaka Lu Kuan Yu
    Upasaka Wen Shu
    Upright
    Vimalakirti
    Vimalakirti Nirdesa Sutra
    Vimalakirti Sutra
    Vinaya Discipline
    Virtue
    Void
    Volition
    Vows
    Vsion
    Wealth
    Wen Shu
    Wisdom
    Wisdon
    Work
    Writing
    WWII
    Xin Ti
    Xu Yun
    Yang Bo
    Yijing
    Yoga Sutra
    Youngman
    Youth
    Yunmen
    Zen
    Zen Dialogue
    Zen Master
    Zuo Hua
    परावृत्ति
    反射
    坐化 - Zou Hua
    恆
    空心地
    释

    RSS Feed

'Licchavi Vimalakirti came to the foot of that tree and said to me, ’Reverend Sariputra, this is not the way to absorb yourself in contemplation. You should absorb yourself in contemplation so that neither body nor mind appear anywhere in the triple world. You should absorb yourself in contemplation in such a way that you can manifest all ordinary behavior without forsaking cessation. You should absorb yourself in contemplation in such a way that you can manifest the nature of an ordinary person without abandoning your cultivated spiritual nature.'
                                                                                                                                                                                        Vimalakirti Nirdesa Sutra


©opyright: Site design, layout & content Richard Hunn Association for Ch’an Study (2012).  No part of this site (or information contained herein) may be copied, reproduced, duplicated,
or otherwise distributed without prior written permission from
chandao@fastmail.fm